Do You Believe Your Eyes And Ears Or SEB?

Do You Believe Your Eyes And Ears Or SEB?

Dramatic and immediate improvement?

Massive and immediate improvement?

Sarawak Energy made a great presentation to the United Nations in Geneva last month, boasting about their plans to resettle the Penan, after forcing them from their homeland in Murum to make way for the latest controversial dam project.

It seemed they were going to be moved from a deprived existence (true, especially since Taib took their forest) and placed into a modern settlement with schools, clinics, training, lands, comfortable accommodation and a great compensation package!

As SEB’s statement to the UN put it:

“These arrangements represent a massive and immediate improvement in the standard of living [for the Penan]”

Make no bones about it, according to SEB, the main beneficiaries of this dam are designed to be the down-trodden local Kenyah and Penan people.

Helping these very tribes is the key ambition of CEO Torstein Sjotveit, as he launches his extraordinary dam building spree in Sarawak. Benefitting these ‘backward’ people is what drives and motivates him, according to endless statements he has made.

His own multi-million dollar salary and Taib’s huge business contracts have nothing to do with it.

Except, in the first film report to come out from the area the Penan are now saying that in fact their lives have become immediately far worse in this new place, which they describe as a hellhole and with good reason.

[youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9GkQWaDCKDU]

Bleak and miserable

Bleak and miserable

Promises are cheap – why did Torstein Sjotveit not put them into a legal contract agreed with the Penan?

It was the same sort of exciting, but extremely vague promises that had persuaded some of the Penan to agree to be moved last month (particularly once SEB started impounding the dam and drowning their homes).

Others are still blockading the dam site and demanding fixed, guaranteed compensation before they agree to move to any resettlement, because they don’t trust verbal promises made by Taib Mahmud.

This is what SEB claimed the Penan would arrive to enjoy "immediately" when they presented their human rights credentials to the United Nations last month

Promise – this is what SEB claimed the Penan would arrive to enjoy “immediately” when they presented their human rights credentials to the United Nations last month

 

Bleak and miserable half-built site

But the truth is very different, despite the upbeat reports that poured out from the pack of journalists who were ferried up to the site by SEB last week as part of a three day all expenses tour to hear the company’s side of the Murum story.

Poorly constructed and filthy - SEB workmanship?

Poorly constructed and filthy – SEB workmanship?

Even the escorted journalists dared to mention that there have been disruptions to water supplies and only limited electricity at the site.

But now the plight of those who have moved to the resettlement area of Tegalung is painfully shown in the new film expose made by the People’s Documentary team, who managed to reach the isolated community.

What they found was a barren building site in the middle of nowhere, with none of the promised schools, clinics or churches and precious little in the way of amenities or lands.

The compensation terms are still vague and incomplete say the resettled folk.

They have no idea what they will eventually receive, if anything.

Nothing has been made clear to the refugees who were moved without guarantees and given just RM15,000.

Nothing has been made clear to the refugees who were moved without guarantees and given just RM15,000.

Judging on the treatment of previous dam refugees in Sarawak they should expect little. The people of Batang Ai and Bakun discovered that many of the things they had been promised for free, like their new homes, running water and electricity came with a price tag that they couldn’t afford.

Bernama PR - plenty of carefully-worded promises, but no legal agreements.  Tegalung does not even have a proper water supply let alone the other items promised.

Bernama dutifully put out SEB’s PR – plenty of carefully-worded promises, but no legal agreements. Tegalung does not even have a proper water supply let alone the other items promised.

Tegalung is bleak and unfinished and the familes are already aimless and listless.  Rice gets dumped on their porch. There is no mention of the so-called agricultural lessons promised to passing journalists last month.

The people of Long Wat who have been moved here are disappointed at shabby buildings and tiny space.  Their electricity is sporadic and water is not adequate.  There is no site of anywhere to grow things and here, in the middle of nowhere, most have no transport.

In the middle of nowhere with no transport and no work. What kind of resettlement expertise was involved that constituted "best practice" in Murum?

In the middle of nowhere with no transport and no work. What kind of resettlement expertise was involved that constituted “best practice” in Murum?

Our pets were left behind to drown

Tragically, neither did SEB fulfil its promise to allow each family enough transport assistance to remove their materials in the 4 hour road trip from their own home. Dogs and chickens and prized possessions were left behind for a second trip that was never provided.

By the time these people returned to Long Wat their home had been burnt by SEB, their valuables destroyed and their pets are presumed dead.

The interview lost his machinery, boat motor and animals in the fire set by SEB. There has been no compensation

Many lost their possessions, machinery, boat motors and animals in the fire set by SEB. There has been no compensation

At the very moment that SEB’s public relations team were bragging at the UN about their “mission in Sarawak” to improve the lives of the Penan, they were conducting the move from Long Wat.  This is what actually happened according to the people now stranded in Tegalung.

“They (the government) had promised to provide 2 cars to carry our things for each family. But during that day, there was 1 car provided in the early morning around 8AM. Another car came around 4PM and left around 7PM. Most of the things we needed were left in the old longhouse and until now we cannot claim back so they were drowned. Including my chainsaw, motor engine and generator, all drowned by the dam since its impoundment”

“Most of our valuables were left in Long Wat to be flooded by the dam.. most of what we needed was left in the old longhouse and until now we cant claim back so they drown – that was due to no more cars provided to carry our things. We have been requesting more transportation but they keep saying there is no more car provided for us.. not only our valuables drowned but our poultry and our dogs drowned together, we were not able to rescue our dogs.”

 

Screen Shot 2013-11-12 at 21.35.48

Uprooted and dumped - best practice for resettling vulnerable tribal peoples?

Uprooted and dumped – best practice for resettling vulnerable tribal peoples?

Torstein Sjotveit has assured the world that his company has been achieving the highest benchmark’s of best practice in its resettlement programme.  We leave viewers to judge for themselves.

Sign-up to receive regular updates from Sarawak Report

We send out the latest story at 7am Malaysia time

Your views are valuable to us, but Sarawak Report kindly requests that comments be deposited in suitable language and do not support racism or violence or we will be forced to withdraw them from the site.

Comments

comments